Essential Reads for Navigating AI and Semiconductor IP Challenges

The rapid evolution of AI systems is intrinsically tied to advances in the processing power of semiconductor devices. The significant market fluctuations caused by these technologies (e.g., the substantial shift experienced by Nvidia following the release of DeepSeek) illustrate their considerable impact on industries and global power dynamics.

As Moore's Law reaches its limits, industry is primed for disruptive innovation to claim a technological and economic edge. Here, we discuss three must-read books that provide insights into AI and semiconductor manufacturing, helping innovators and IP professionals understand the technological, financial, and geopolitical forces that affect their IP strategies.

Chip War: The Fight for the World's Most Critical Technology by Chris Miller

In Chip War, Chris Miller chronicles the significant developments in semiconductor manufacturing, from the first transistor to extreme ultraviolet light. Miller's narrative keeps the reader riveted with episodes ranging from widespread corporate espionage to semiconductor manufacturing as evangelism. What binds the globe-spanning story together is the universal language of human ambition. Miller leaves it to the reader to decide if monetary, technological, or egotistic ambition produced the most significant impact.

Miller thoroughly analyzes the economic and geopolitical forces that led to the concentration of semiconductor manufacturing in pockets around the globe. The transition to a distributed supply chain, where Taiwanese companies like TSMC fabricate chips that American companies like Nvidia design, has enabled innovators to generate tremendous profits and innovation. However, Miller reminds us that chips form the backbone of military power and shows how the US and its allies exert political power by applying pressure to the semiconductor supply chain. Miller demonstrates how struggles to secure critical patents and trade secrets have shaped the industry.

Why this book matters

Chip War is an engaging read for anyone interested in semiconductors, business development, or geopolitics. Innovators can leave the book with a deeper understanding of intellectual property's strategic role in the global semiconductor landscape.

The AI Advantage: How to Put the Artificial Intelligence Revolution to Work by Thomas H. Davenport

The AI Advantage provides an encyclopedic collection of AI practices, trends, and use cases. The book offers a comprehensive overview of the options for businesses looking to leverage AI's competitive advantage. While Davenport provides a granular analysis of real-world AI applications, he includes such a wealth of knowledge and genuinely interesting analysis that the text feels like a series of conversational seminars. In Davenport's words, AI offers "a lot of business value, but much of that value isn't terribly sexy or visible. Products and processes will be made somewhat better and easier to use. Decisions will be better informed."

The book guides companies to take a pragmatic approach to their AI strategies and prioritize immediate business value rather than speculative future scenarios. Those looking to implement viable products should consider the "relatively few examples of radical transformation with cognitive technologies actually succeeding, and many examples of 'low hanging fruit' being successfully picked." In the short term, companies can create opportunities for efficiency and innovation by investing in AI that augments human decision-making rather than entirely replacing it.

A central thesis of the book is that AI works best alongside humans. Davenport uses several deployments of IBM's Watson as case studies that reveal the limitations of totally independent AI systems. Davenport stresses the necessity of human-machine collaboration. In his view, the companies that will dominate the future are "those who identify and nurture effective collaborations between humans and machines."

Why this book matters

The AI Advantage outlines a framework for success that businesses interested in AI solutions can readily adopt. Davenport recommends investing steadily, tuning out the hype, and ensuring AI is well-suited to solving your business problems.

Power and Prediction: The Disruptive Economics of Artificial Intelligence by Ajay Agrawal, Joshua Gans, and Avi Goldfarb

Power and Prediction is a follow-up to the author's earlier work, Prediction Machines, which focused on the disruptive potential of AI technologies. In Power and Prediction, the authors aim to identify the factors that lead to market disruption. The book contains a series of strategies for determining when market disruption produces opportunities to generate economic wealth. Fully leveraging AI systems requires understanding both the technology and its societal constraints. We are currently in "the between times" – after witnessing AI's potential but before the invention of new operating methods that fully unlock its power.

The authors break down solutions that implement new technologies into point, application, and system solutions.

Point solutions replace specific tasks with new technology without changing the surrounding system. A notable point solution is the use of AI to analyze radiology scans. The authors describe how deep learning models and experienced radiologists identify diseases in X-rays and MRI scans with similar levels of accuracy. Radiologists add value because these AI systems automate diagnosing diseases while leaving the broader patient care system undisturbed.

Application solutions improve components of an existing system, and users implement them without changes to the broader system in which they operate. The book describes a restaurant demand prediction where restaurants use AI to predict customer demand. The restaurant demand prediction application minimizes the amount of excess food purchased and enhances profitability without requiring significant modifications to the restaurant supply chain.

System solutions involve redesigning entire systems and processes to capitalize on AI's capabilities fully. A system implementation of the restaurant prediction tool would have AI monitor and control the output of food suppliers. The AI might predict what the restaurant will need on any given day. The prediction tool would then deliver the supplies before the restaurant owner places an order. The book notes that many retailers, like Amazon, have considered but not implemented such approaches.

The authors use the water crisis in Flint, Michigan, as a case study illustrating the obstacles to implementing AI prediction tools in real-world systems. Many of the residents of Flint had lead pipes leading to their homes. The city was interested in replacing the pipes but realized it was difficult to determine which houses had lead pipes and which did not.

University of Michigan professors developed a point solution AI tool that was 80% accurate at predicting which houses in Flint had lead pipes. The 20% false positive rate cost was significantly lower than the alternative solution of digging up all the pipes in every home. However, because acting on the AI's prediction required displacing real humans, navigating local politics, and digging up actual pipes, the AI tool was initially sidelined.

Flint finally implemented the tool after a court order removed the deciding power from local politicians. The AI tool's prediction provided valuable benefits, but the system of deciding whether or not to use the tool needed to change before the people of Flint could realize those benefits.

The authors draw a parallel between AI and electricity, noting that "by 1880, it was clear that electricity had great potential to improve how factories operate," yet the full realization of its benefits in 1920 required decades of further development. They believe that "with AI, we are closer to 1880 than 1920."

Why this book matters

Power and Prediction frames AI as a general-purpose technology whose adoption will likely mirror previous general-purpose technologies (like steam, electricity, and the internet). These technologies evolved from point solutions to applications, ultimately leading to system-level change.

The authors note that system solutions have the potential for the most transformative change but require years and often decades of incremental improvement through point and application solutions before they become viable or fully realized. Capitalizing on the short-term benefits of AI point solutions will continue to generate patents and trade secrets that companies and IP professionals can use to protect valuable innovation.

Conclusion

These three books provide complementary perspectives essential for IP professionals and business owners. Market disruption – or the winners and losers of it – emerges as a common theme for all authors. From Henry Ford's assembly line to Intel's pivot to microprocessors, companies can corner entire markets by strategic investment in transformative technologies. AI represents such a technology, and innovators can look to these books for strategies for successful market disruption.

Together, these works underscore that intellectual property in these fields exists within complex technical, economic, and geopolitical contexts. Effective IP counsel requires legal expertise and a deep understanding of these broader forces shaping technology development and deployment. As these technologies evolve and converge, IP professionals and business owners must remain vigilant to protect their valuable IP while navigating an increasingly complex global landscape.

At Bright-Line IP, we've helped clients, from startups to multinational corporations, maximize the value of their innovations by strategically developing a patent portfolio.

Whether you're looking to protect a groundbreaking technology or secure your market position in key countries, we're here to guide you every step of the way.

Ready to protect your AI solution? Contact Bright-Line IP today to discuss developing a winning IP strategy.

Disclosure: This review contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources:

1. Chris Miller, Chip War: The Fight for the World's Most Critical Technology (1st ed. 2022). https://amzn.to/3FmP4dd

2. Thomas H. Davenport, The AI Advantage: How to Put the Artificial Intelligence Revolution to Work (MIT Press 2018). https://amzn.to/4bKWmDB

3. Ajay Agrawal, Joshua Gans & Avi Goldfarb, Power and Prediction: The Disruptive Economics of Artificial Intelligence (Harvard Business Review Press 2022). https://amzn.to/41USc8P